As Congress lurches closer to a decision on an enormous
overhaul of the American health care system, pressure is
mounting on legislative leaders to make the final bill available
online for citizens to read before a vote.
Lawmakers were given just hours to examine the $789 billion
stimulus plan, sweeping climate change legislation and a $700
billion bailout package before final votes.
While most Americans normally ignore parliamentary detail, with health care looming, voters are suddenly
paying attention. The Senate is expected to vote on a health bill in the weeks to come, representing months
of work and stretching to hundreds of pages. And as of now, there is no assurance that members of the
public, or even the senators themselves, will be given the chance to read the legislation before a vote."The American people are now suspicious of not only the lawmakers, but the process they hide behind to do
their work," said Michael Franc, president of government relations for the Heritage Foundation, a
conservative think tank.
At town hall meetings across the country this past summer, the main topic was health care, but there was a
strong undercurrent of anger over the way Congress rushed through passage of the stimulus, global warming
and bank bailout bills without seeming to understand the consequences. The stimulus bill, for example, was
1,100 pages long and made available to Congress and the public just 13 hours before lawmakers voted on it.
The bill has failed to provide the promised help to the job market, and there was outrage when it was
discovered that the legislation included an amendment allowing American International Group, a bailout
recipient, to give out millions in employee bonuses."If someone had a chance to look at the bill, they would have found that out," said Lisa Rosenberg, who
lobbies Congress on behalf of the Sunlight Foundation to bring more transparency to government.
The foundation has begun an effort to get Congress to post bills online, for all to see, 72 hours before
lawmakers vote on them.
"It would give the public a chance to really digest and understand what is in the bill," Rosenberg said, "and
communicate whether that is a good or a bad thing while there is still time to fix it."
What you don't know can hurt you:
» House energy and global warming bill, passed June 26, 2009. 1,200 pages. Available online 15 hours before
» $789 billion stimulus bill, passed Feb. 14, 2009. 1,100 pages. Available online 13 hours before debate.
» $700 billion financial sector rescue package, passed Oct. 3, 2008. 169 pages. Available online 29 hours
» USA Patriot domestic surveillance bill, passed Oct. 23, 2001. Unavailable to the public before debate.
A similar effort is under way in Congress. Reps. Brian Baird, D‐Wash., and Greg Walden, R‐Ore., are
circulating a petition among House lawmakers that would force a vote on the 72 hour rule.
Nearly every Republican has signed on, but the Democratic leadership is unwilling to cede control over when
bills are brought to the floor for votes and are discouraging their rank and file from signing the petition.
Senate Democrats voted down a similar measure last week for the health care bill.
The reluctance to implement a three day rule is not unique to the Democrats.
The Republican majority rushed through the controversial Patriot Act in the wake of the Sept. 11, 2001,
terrorist attacks as well as a massive Medicare prescription drug bill in 2003 that added hundreds of billions
of dollars to the deficit.
For the majority party, legislative timing plays a big role in whether a bill will pass because support can be
fleeting."The leaders use it as a tool to get votes or to keep amendments off a bill," said one top Senate Democratic
But Baird warned of public backlash.
"Democrats know politically it's difficult to defend not doing this," he said. "The public gets this. They say we
entrust you with the profound responsibility of making decisions that affect our lives, and we expect you to
exercise due diligence in carrying out that responsibility."
All information posted on this web site is
the opinion of the author and is provided for educational purposes only.
It is not to be construed as medical advice. Only a licensed medical doctor
can legally offer medical advice in the United States. Consult the healer
of your choice for medical care and advice.